Rivista Scientifica di Diritto e Giurisprudenza
Diritto Civile • Amministrativo • Lavoro • Penale • Tributario • ISSN 3103-7305
Editor-in-Chief & Co-Scientific Director Metodo Giuridico • ISSN 3103-7305

Bruno Taverniti

Attorney at the Rome Bar — Editor-in-Chief of Metodo Giuridico

Practises civil law and administrative law. His contributions adopt a direct technical approach strictly grounded in case-law analysis.

58
Published Contributions
4
Full-Text English Papers
8
Doctrinal Essays
50
Case Notes

Research Disciplines & Indexed Descriptors (JEL / EU EuroVoc)

Primary Legal Areas: Law of Obligations & Contracts (20) Tort & Civil Liability Law (6) Environmental & Energy Law (5) Planning, Zoning & Construction Law (4) Public Procurement & Government Contracts (3) Banking & Financial Law (3)

Chronological Bibliography in Metodo Giuridico

ISSN 3103-7305 • Diamond Open Access (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0)
Showing all 58 published papers (newest first)
Doctrinal Essay Public Procurement & Government Contracts IT + EN Full-Text
Vol. 1, Issue 3 (2026) • Art. 6692 • November 13, 2026

ANAC Sanctioning Powers in Public Procurement Require Actual Proof of Harm

The ANAC sanctioning power over public procurement safeguards the qualification system of contracting authorities and central purchasing bodies within the AUSA registry pursuant to Article 63 of Legislative Decree no. 36/2023. The Authority's enforcement…

Supreme Court Case Note Damages & Compensation Law IT + EN Full-Text
Vol. 1, Issue 3 (2026) • Art. 6634 • November 11, 2026

Parental Bereavement Damages for the Conceived Child upon Live Birth

This paper examines the recoverability of parental damage for a child conceived prior to the tortious event but born subsequently, as referred to a public hearing by interlocutory order no. 12460/2026 of the Civil Court of Cassation. By harmonizing the…

Supreme Court Case Note Property & Real Rights Law IT + EN Full-Text
Vol. 1, Issue 3 (2026) • Art. 6600 • November 9, 2026

Adverse Possession of Easements with Unlawful Structures and Statutory Setbacks

This article analyses judgment no. 24767/2026 of the Italian Supreme Court on the adverse possession of building easements built in violation of statutory setback limits and without administrative permits. The author examines the distinction between private…

Supreme Court Case Note Tort & Civil Liability Law IT + EN Full-Text
Vol. 1, Issue 3 (2026) • Art. 6453 • November 3, 2026

Strict Liability for Things in Custody and the Burden of the Unknown Cause

This paper analyzes the objective liability regime for damage caused by things in custody under Article 2051 of the Italian Civil Code, with specific reference to Civil Court of Cassation order no. 15662/2026. The Supreme Court establishes that the injured…

Supreme Court Case Note Law of Obligations & Contracts
Vol. 1, Issue 3 (2026) • Art. 6392 • November 2, 2026

Ex Officio Judicial Reduction of Penalty Clauses and Powers of the Trial Judge

Italian original: Riduzione d’ufficio della clausola penale e poteri del giudice

This essay provides an in-depth examination of the ex officio reduction of penalty clauses in the wake of Supreme Court order no. 25061/2025. The study explores the doctrinal interplay between judicial equitable intervention under Article 1384 of the Italian…

Supreme Court Case Note Corporate Crisis & Insolvency Law
Vol. 1, Issue 3 (2026) • Art. 6312 • October 30, 2026

Forfeiture of Suretyship Guarantees in Preventive Composition with Creditors

Italian original: La decadenza della fideiussione nel concordato preventivo

Civil Court of Cassation order no. 8733/2025 clarifies the rules governing the forfeiture of personal guarantees under Article 1957 of the Italian Civil Code when the principal debtor enters composition with creditors. Accelerated debt maturity obliges the…

Supreme Court Case Note Tort & Civil Liability Law
Vol. 1, Issue 3 (2026) • Art. 6299 • October 29, 2026

Severe Construction Defects in Buildings and Remedies for Material Damage

Italian original: Gravi difetti dell’immobile e risarcimento del danno edilizio

This article examines Order no. 3011/2025 delivered by the Italian Court of Cassation regarding severe construction defects and water infiltration issues. The Court reaffirms the power of the appellate judge to reclassify claims from contractual guarantees…

Supreme Court Case Note Tort & Civil Liability Law
Vol. 1, Issue 3 (2026) • Art. 6226 • October 27, 2026

Custodial Liability for Falls and the Comparative Fault of the Injured Party

Italian original: La responsabilità da custodia e condotta del danneggiato nella caduta

In order no. 5069 of March 6, 2026, the Italian Court of Cassation addressed the critical intersection between custodial liability under Article 2051 of the Civil Code and the victim's comparative negligence. The Supreme Court quashed the appellate judgment…

Supreme Court Case Note Banking & Financial Law
Vol. 1, Issue 3 (2026) • Art. 6211 • October 26, 2026

First-Demand Guarantees and the Limits of Creditor Forfeiture

Italian original: Fideiussione a prima richiesta e decadenza del creditore: i limiti

In order no. 21564 of 24 June 2026, the Italian Supreme Court of Cassation clarifies the interplay between first-demand payment clauses and the creditor's forfeiture rule under Article 1957 of the Italian Civil Code. The Court establishes that, while a…

Supreme Court Case Note Law of Obligations & Contracts
Vol. 1, Issue 3 (2026) • Art. 5045 • October 23, 2026

Termination of Preliminary Contracts, Confirmatory Deposit, Withdrawal, and Damages

Italian original: Risoluzione del preliminare e caparra confirmatoria: recesso e danno

This article examines the procedural and substantive interplay between judicial termination for breach, statutory withdrawal with forfeiture of the confirmatory deposit, and subsequent bankruptcy proceedings. When the non-breaching party combines a claim for…

Supreme Court Case Note Law of Obligations & Contracts
Vol. 1, Issue 3 (2026) • Art. 5033 • October 22, 2026

Client Unilateral Withdrawal and Contractor Breach in Service and Construction Contracts

Italian original: Recesso del committente e inadempimento nell’appalto: oneri e tutele

This article analyzes the relationship between contractual termination for breach and the client’s statutory right of withdrawal in service and construction contracts. When performance is interrupted prior to final completion, the strict requirement of total…

Supreme Court Case Note Law of Obligations & Contracts
Vol. 1, Issue 3 (2026) • Art. 5003 • October 20, 2026

Wastewater Purification Tariffs, Third-Party Cooperation, and Internal Recourse Actions

Italian original: Canone di depurazione e cooperazione del terzo: il regresso

The Italian Court of Cassation, in order no. 26185/2026, clarifies the remedial structure governing the purification fee and third-party cooperation in breach of contract. When wastewater purification facilities remain inoperative, the water supply company…

Supreme Court Case Note Tort & Civil Liability Law
Vol. 1, Issue 3 (2026) • Art. 4994 • October 20, 2026

Constructor Liability for Serious Building Defects and the Concurrence of Legal Actions

Italian original: Responsabilità per gravi difetti dell’immobile: il concorso di azioni

With interlocutory order no. 26951/2026, the Italian Court of Cassation referred to a public hearing the fundamental question concerning constructor liability for serious defects in buildings. The core legal issue is whether the injured party may invoke the…

Supreme Court Case Note Succession & Estates Law
Vol. 1, Issue 3 (2026) • Art. 4910 • October 16, 2026

Atypical Life Maintenance Annuities and Lack of Aleatory Risk: Contractual Nullity

Italian original: Vitalizio assistenziale e difetto di alea: la nullità

In judgment No. 25952 of September 29, 2026, the Italian Court of Cassation defines the requirements for atypical maintenance contracts. The evaluation of contractual risk mandates an ex-ante economic comparison between the capitalized yield of the…

Supreme Court Case Note Family Law
Vol. 1, Issue 3 (2026) • Art. 4904 • October 16, 2026

Support Administration for Strictly Physical Disabilities and the Limits of Judicial Imposition

Italian original: Amministrazione di sostegno e disabilità fisica: i limiti

Order no. 25747 of 23 September 2026 of the Civil Court of Cassation clarifies the legal boundaries between support administration and physical disability. The Supreme Court reaffirms that severe physical impairment, even when officially certified with total…

Doctrinal Essay Banking & Financial Law
Vol. 1, Issue 3 (2026) • Art. 4901 • October 16, 2026

Consumer Guarantors and Implicit Res Judicata: Ex Officio Review of Unfair Terms

Italian original: Fideiussore consumatore e giudicato implicito: la CGUE

The order of the Court of Justice of the European Union of 6 October 2026 in case C-667/24 clarifies the relationship between the consumer guarantor and implicit res judicata. The Court holds that Articles 6 and 7 of Directive 93/13/EEC and Article 47 of the…

Supreme Court Case Note Family Law
Vol. 1, Issue 3 (2026) • Art. 4880 • October 15, 2026

Derogation from Spousal Consent in the Administration of the Family Patrimonial Fund

Italian original: La deroga al consenso dei coniugi nel fondo patrimoniale

By order no. 26531 of October 9, 2026, the Italian Court of Cassation consolidates its case law regarding the scope of party autonomy in the administration of the family trust fund (fondo patrimoniale). The ruling addresses the validity of real estate…

Supreme Court Case Note Family Law
Vol. 1, Issue 3 (2026) • Art. 4859 • October 14, 2026

Family Patrimonial Funds and Personal Guarantees: Limits of Nuclear Family Protection

Italian original: Fondo patrimoniale e fideiussione: il limite della famiglia nucleare

The relationship between a family patrimonial fund and a personal guarantee for corporate debts is clarified by the Italian Supreme Court of Cassation, Civil Division, in judgment no. 24595 of August 10, 2026. The Court rules that the asset segregation…

Doctrinal Essay Environmental & Energy Law
Vol. 1, Issue 3 (2026) • Art. 4734 • October 9, 2026

Legislative Delegation for Sustainable Nuclear Energy, Regional Competence, and Referendums

Italian original: Delega per l’energia nucleare sostenibile tra Regioni e referendum

Law no. 169 of 29 September 2026 introduces a complex delegation for sustainable nuclear energy, outlining the deployment of innovative modular reactors through a single state authorization. This article critically examines the constitutional robustness of…

Supreme Court Case Note Law of Obligations & Contracts
Vol. 1, Issue 3 (2026) • Art. 4681 • October 6, 2026

Preliminary Sale with Early Possession: Confirmatory Deposit and Indemnity for Occupation

Italian original: Preliminare con consegna anticipata: caparra e indennità

The Italian Court of Cassation, in civil order no. 24687/2026, establishes that upon termination by withdrawal of a preliminary sale agreement with anticipatory handover of the property due to the buyer's breach, the seller is entitled both to forfeit the…

Supreme Court Case Note Law of Obligations & Contracts
Vol. 1, Issue 3 (2026) • Art. 4614 • October 2, 2026

Internal Recourse among Joint Debtors: Allocation Based on the Debt Actually Enforced

Italian original: Regresso tra condebitori solidali: riparto su credito azionato

This article examines the internal allocation regime among jointly and severally liable co-debtors following order no. 19492/2025 of the Italian Civil Supreme Court. The paper explores the transition from external joint liability to the internal proportional…

Supreme Court Case Note Banking & Financial Law
Vol. 1, Issue 3 (2026) • Art. 4598 • October 1, 2026

Omnibus Guarantees and Standard ABI Clauses: Creditor Forfeiture and Guarantor Relief

Italian original: Fideiussione omnibus e clausole ABI: la decadenza del garante

This article examines civil order no. 24277/2026 of the Italian Court of Cassation concerning omnibus guarantees conforming to the standard ABI contract sanctioned by Bank of Italy Decision no. 55/2005. The analysis addresses the mechanism of special partial…

Supreme Court Case Note Condominium & Real Estate Law
Vol. 1, Issue 2 (2026) • Art. 4549 • September 28, 2026

Water Infiltrations from Rooftop Terraces: Joint Liability of Condominium and Exclusive User

Italian original: Infiltrazioni dal lastrico solare e responsabilità solidale

The judgment under review rigorously examines the civil liability regime governing water infiltration damages originating from a rooftop terrace held in exclusive use, arising from the concurrent causation between structural defects in condominium drainage…

Supreme Court Case Note Tort & Civil Liability Law
Vol. 1, Issue 2 (2026) • Art. 4451 • September 24, 2026

Medical Malpractice and Court-Appointed Experts: Burden of Proof and Internal Contribution

Italian original: Responsabilità medica e CTU: prova del danno e riparto interno

This article analyses the judgment of the Court of Isernia, Civil Section, 17 August 2026, no. 449, addressing the substantial and evidentiary framework governing medical malpractice prior to Law no. 24/2017. The ruling highlights the evidentiary role of…

Supreme Court Case Note Law of Obligations & Contracts
Vol. 1, Issue 2 (2026) • Art. 4428 • September 23, 2026

Contractual Nullity: Ex Officio Judicial Powers Subordinate to Res Judicata

Italian original: Nullità del contratto: il rilievo officioso cede al giudicato

The Court of Cassation, First Civil Section, order no. 25257 of September 13, 2026, defines the boundaries of the appellate court's power to raise contract nullity ex officio. The ruling clarifies the relationship between the ex officio plea under Article…

Supreme Court Case Note Tort & Civil Liability Law
Vol. 1, Issue 2 (2026) • Art. 4042 • September 21, 2026

Professional Legal Negligence: No Actionable Damages without Proof of Likely Success

Italian original: Avvocato negligente: niente danno senza prova di vittoria

The procedural breach of a defense attorney, culminating in the inadmissibility of an appeal or irreparable forfeitures, does not inherently constitute compensable damage for the client. The professional liability of lawyers, according to the strict ruling…

Doctrinal Essay Corporate Crisis & Insolvency Law
Vol. 1, Issue 2 (2026) • Art. 4000 • September 17, 2026

Ordinary Revocatory Action: Substantive Prerequisites, Burden of Proof, and Prescription

Italian original: Azione revocatoria: presupposti, onere della prova e prescrizione

The analysis of the prerequisites for the ordinary revocatory action under Articles 2901 et seq. of the Italian Civil Code requires a rigorous delineation of objective harm and the burden of proof. The established orientation of the Supreme Court clarifies…

Supreme Court Case Note Law of Obligations & Contracts
Vol. 1, Issue 2 (2026) • Art. 3988 • September 16, 2026

Contract Termination for Breach: Confirmatory Deposit Cannot Be Retained without Withdrawal

Italian original: Risoluzione del contratto: la caparra non si trattiene senza recesso

What happens to a confirmatory deposit when a preliminary contract is terminated for the breach of the party who paid it, but the recipient never exercised the right of withdrawal? In ruling no. 8573 of 2026 the Italian Court of Cassation first confirms that…

Supreme Court Case Note Law of Obligations & Contracts
Vol. 1, Issue 2 (2026) • Art. 3976 • September 15, 2026

Void Contracts with Public Administrations and Action for Unjustified Enrichment

Italian original: Contratto nullo con la P.A.: ammesso l’arricchimento senza causa

The unjustified enrichment claim represents a pivotal subsidiary remedy for rebalancing wealth transfers resulting from performances executed without legal formal requirements. With judgment No. 11513 of 28 April 2026, the Joint Civil Chambers of the Italian…

Supreme Court Case Note Law of Obligations & Contracts
Vol. 1, Issue 2 (2026) • Art. 3918 • September 9, 2026

Penalty Clauses: Ex Officio Judicial Reduction Requires Prior Adversarial Argument

Italian original: Clausola penale: la riduzione d’ufficio impone il contraddittorio

By Order No. 13024 of 2026, the Italian Court of Cassation clarifies the procedural limits governing the trial court's equitable powers. The decision addresses the ex officio reduction of penalty clauses under Article 1384 of the Italian Civil Code, an…

Supreme Court Case Note Law of Obligations & Contracts
Vol. 1, Issue 2 (2026) • Art. 3903 • September 8, 2026

Contractual Withdrawal with Confirmatory Deposit Does Not Require an Express Termination Clause

Italian original: Recesso con caparra confirmatoria: non serve clausola risolutiva

Order no. 16999/2026 of the Italian Court of Cassation (Second Civil Section) holds that withdrawal from a preliminary sale contract with earnest money (caparra confirmatoria) under Article 1385, paragraph 2, of the Civil Code does not require an express…

Supreme Court Case Note White-Collar, Corporate & Tax Crime
Vol. 1, Issue 2 (2026) • Art. 3852 • September 4, 2026

Corporate Disloyalty, Breach of Trust, and Compensatory Group Advantages

Italian original: Infedeltà patrimoniale e vantaggi compensativi di gruppo

This paper analyzes Italian Court of Cassation (Third Criminal Section) Judgment no. 29617 of 5 August 2026 on corporate disloyalty within business groups and interim asset freezes. The study explores the statutory requirements of compensatory advantages…

Supreme Court Case Note Planning, Zoning & Construction Law
Vol. 1, Issue 2 (2026) • Art. 3843 • September 3, 2026

Tacit Consent and Zoning Non-Compliance in Administrative Building Procedures

Italian original: Silenzio assenso e difformità urbanistiche nel procedimento

This paper examines Italian Council of State (Fourth Section) Judgment no. 2179 of 8 March 2026 regarding the tacit grant of building permits under Article 20 of Presidential Decree no. 380/2001. The analysis focuses on the distinction between structural and…

Supreme Court Case Note Law of Obligations & Contracts
Vol. 1, Issue 2 (2026) • Art. 3819 • September 1, 2026

Preliminary Real Estate Sale with Early Delivery, Building Irregularities, and Occupation

Italian original: Preliminare con consegna anticipata, abuso edilizio e occupazione

This article examines Italian Supreme Court (Second Civil Section) judgment no. 4074 of 23 February 2026 regarding preliminary real estate sale contracts with early delivery and total incurable building irregularities. The analysis investigates the…

Supreme Court Case Note Precautionary & Asset Forfeiture Measures
Vol. 1, Issue 2 (2026) • Art. 3737 • August 28, 2026

Appellate Review of Preventive Seizure and the Requirement of Actual Interest to Challenge

Italian original: Riesame del sequestro preventivo e interesse concreto ad impugnare

This article analyses the landmark judgment of the United Chambers of the Italian Supreme Court of Cassation, criminal judgment of 27 February 2026, no. 7983, concerning the review (riesame) of preventive seizure and the requirement of a concrete legal…

Supreme Court Case Note Law of Obligations & Contracts
Vol. 1, Issue 2 (2026) • Art. 3702 • August 26, 2026

Express Termination Clauses and Good Faith: Limits of Judicial Review in Contract Law

Italian original: Clausola risolutiva espressa e buona fede: i limiti del giudice

The Italian Supreme Court (Order No. 19211 of June 11, 2026) firmly establishes the boundaries of judicial review under the principle of contractual good faith (Art. 1375 of the Italian Civil Code), holding that courts may not alter the contractual terms by…

Supreme Court Case Note Law of Obligations & Contracts
Vol. 1, Issue 2 (2026) • Art. 3691 • August 25, 2026

Confirmatory Deposit and Contractual Termination: Prohibition of Cumulative Damages

Italian original: Caparra confirmatoria e risoluzione: vietato il cumulo dei danni

The Italian Supreme Court of Cassation (Second Civil Division, Judgment no. 4301 of 25 February 2026) held that a claim seeking judicial termination of a contract coupled with compensation for full damages precludes the retention of the confirmatory deposit…

Supreme Court Case Note Law of Obligations & Contracts
Vol. 1, Issue 2 (2026) • Art. 3677 • August 24, 2026

Termination of Preliminary Sale Agreements and Assessment of Definitive Damages

Italian original: Risoluzione del preliminare e quantificazione del danno definitivo

This article examines order no. 17523/2026 delivered by the Italian Supreme Court of Cassation regarding the termination of preliminary real estate contracts and the assessment of compensatory damages for definitive breach of contract. The Court addresses…

Supreme Court Case Note Law of Obligations & Contracts
Vol. 1, Issue 2 (2026) • Art. 3622 • August 21, 2026

Preliminary Contracts with Anticipated Effects: Restitutionary Claims and Default

Italian original: Preliminare ad effetti anticipati: restituzioni e inadempimenti

The Second Civil Section of the Italian Supreme Court of Cassation, with judgment no. 16917 of May 29, 2026, consolidates the legal principles governing the termination of preliminary contracts for the sale of real estate with advance performance in the…

Supreme Court Case Note Law of Obligations & Contracts
Vol. 1, Issue 2 (2026) • Art. 3604 • August 19, 2026

Penalty Clauses in Preliminary Real Estate Contracts and Consumer Protection Standards

Italian original: Clausola penale nel preliminare: la tutela del consumatore

Judgment no. 21771 delivered on June 25, 2026 by the Second Civil Chamber of the Italian Supreme Court of Cassation represents a crucial milestone concerning penalty clauses within preliminary real estate purchase agreements between professionals and…

Supreme Court Case Note Planning, Zoning & Construction Law
Vol. 1, Issue 2 (2026) • Art. 3567 • August 17, 2026

Building Permits and Landscape Constraints Under Evolving Administrative Case Law

Italian original: Permesso di costruire e vincolo paesaggistico nel nuovo orientamento

This paper examines Council of State Judgment No. 6099 of 2026. The Court ruled that landscape restrictions prevent tacit approval for building permits under Presidential Decree 380/2001, but require public authorities to engage in procedural cooperation and…

Doctrinal Essay Tax Litigation & Procedure
Vol. 1, Issue 2 (2026) • Art. 3474 • August 10, 2026

The Binding Effect of Final Criminal Judgments in Tax Litigation Proceedings

Italian original: L’efficacia del giudicato penale nel processo tributario

This in-depth legal analysis examines the binding effect of final criminal acquittals within tax proceedings following Constitutional Court judgment no. 50 of 13 April 2026. The Court upheld Article 21-bis of Legislative Decree 74/2000, validating the res…

Supreme Court Case Note Public Procurement & Government Contracts
Vol. 1, Issue 2 (2026) • Art. 2347 • August 7, 2026

Workforce Absorption Plans and Social Clauses in Public Procurement Tenders

Italian original: Progetto di assorbimento e clausola sociale negli appalti

This article analyzes Council of State Fifth Section ruling no. 2878 of 2 April 2026. The Court established that under Articles 57 and 102 of Legislative Decree 36/2023, the staff absorption plan for social clauses is an essential structural component of…

Doctrinal Essay Environmental & Energy Law
Vol. 1, Issue 2 (2026) • Art. 1824 • July 23, 2026

Implementing a Just Transition Towards Climate Neutrality in European Governance

Italian original: L’attuazione della transizione equa verso la neutralità climatica

The 2026 full progress review conducted by the European Commission provides a comprehensive evaluation of the implementation of the Council Recommendation of 16 June 2022 on ensuring a fair transition towards climate neutrality. Examining over 500 measures…

Supreme Court Case Note Environmental & Energy Law
Vol. 1, Issue 2 (2026) • Art. 1597 • July 15, 2026

Suitability of Agricultural Areas for Renewable Energy Plants: Alternative Statutory Criteria

Italian original: Idoneità delle aree agricole: i criteri FER sono alternativi

The Council of State, with judgment no. 1099/2026, defines the criteria for the suitability of agricultural areas for ground-mounted photovoltaic systems. The court clarifies that the cases set forth in Article 20, paragraph 8 of Legislative Decree no.…

Supreme Court Case Note Public Entities & Concessions
Vol. 1, Issue 2 (2026) • Art. 1476 • July 10, 2026

Incentive Tariffs for In-House Providing Entities: Exclusion of Statutory Exemptions

Italian original: Tariffe incentivanti per società in house: no alla deroga

The Constitutional Court, with judgment no. 103 of June 11, 2026, excluded that the exemptions on incentive tariffs for in-house companies (tariffe incentivanti per società in house) in the photovoltaic sector can be extended through interpretation or…

Supreme Court Case Note Social Security & Welfare Law
Vol. 1, Issue 2 (2026) • Art. 1424 • July 9, 2026

Recovery of Undue Welfare Benefits: Dual Regulatory Regimes and Good Faith Protection

Italian original: Ripetibilità dell’indebito assistenziale: i due regimi

The judgment no. 387/2026 of the Court of Appeal of Lecce reaffirms the clear distinction between healthcare-related and income-related welfare benefit overpayments. In the former case, recovery runs from the communication of the review report to the…

Doctrinal Essay Environmental & Energy Law
Vol. 1, Issue 2 (2026) • Art. 1336 • July 7, 2026

Climate Neutrality in European Union Law: Binding Targets and Governance Frameworks

Italian original: La neutralità climatica nel diritto dell’Unione europea

Regulation (EU) 2021/1119, as amended by Regulation (EU) 2026/667, introduces a binding intermediate target for 2040, requiring a 90% net reduction in greenhouse gas emissions compared to 1990 levels. This article examines the legal nature of this aggregated…

Supreme Court Case Note Public Entities & Concessions
Vol. 1, Issue 1 (2026) • Art. 1279 • June 24, 2026

Operational Risk Transfer and Legal Qualification of Public Service Concessions

Italian original: Rischio operativo e qualificazione della concessione di servizi

This note analyzes the ruling of the regional administrative court (TAR Lazio no. 11011/2026) regarding the concession of bar and catering services at the Auditorium Parco della Musica in Rome. The decision examines the criteria to distinguish between the…

Supreme Court Case Note Administrative Justice & Litigation
Vol. 1, Issue 1 (2026) • Art. 1178 • June 9, 2026

Access to Procurement Documents: Fast-Track Procedure Between Administrative Inertia and Defects

Italian original: Accesso agli atti: rito superaccelerato tra inerzia e vizio

This article analyzes the operational conditions of the super-accelerated access procedure under Article 36 of Legislative Decree No. 36/2023, in light of the Council of State judgment No. 4105/2026. The author examines the distinction between the radical…

Supreme Court Case Note Planning, Zoning & Construction Law
Vol. 1, Issue 1 (2026) • Art. 1146 • June 4, 2026

Urban Planning Compliance as a Prerequisite for Lawful Commercial Activities

Italian original: Nesso tra la regolarità urbanistica e l’attività commerciale

This paper analyzes judgment no. 3744/2026 of the Council of State, centered on the connection between urban compliance and commercial activity carried out on civic domain lands. The essay first examines the procedural perimeter of the status of interested…

Supreme Court Case Note Public Procurement & Government Contracts
Vol. 1, Issue 1 (2026) • Art. 1125 • May 30, 2026

Distinction Between Concierge Services and Armed Private Security in Public Contracts

Italian original: La distinzione tra portierato e vigilanza privata negli appalti

This note examines the TAR Lazio judgment no. 9395/2026, focusing on the distinction between porterage and private security services in public procurement. Embracing criminal jurisprudence principles, the Court classifies dynamic inspection services and the…

Supreme Court Case Note Law of Obligations & Contracts
Vol. 1, Issue 1 (2026) • Art. 1061 • May 26, 2026

Unjust Enrichment Claims in Public Procurement and Nullity for Lack of Written Form

Italian original: Arricchimento senza causa e contratti pubblici: difetto di forma

This paper analyzes the availability of the action for unjust enrichment when public contracts are void for lack of written form. Following Cass. Sez. Un. n. 11513/2026, the study examines the rule of subsidiarity under art. 2042 c.c. and its relationship…

Doctrinal Essay Environmental & Energy Law
Vol. 1, Issue 1 (2026) • Art. 760 • April 29, 2026

Allocation of Jurisdiction in the Recovery of Renewable Energy Tariffs and Subsidies

Italian original: Il riparto di giurisdizione nel recupero degli incentivi energetici: profili sistematici

This paper examines the complex issue of allocation of jurisdiction regarding renewable energy incentives, focusing on the recovery claims brought by the Energy Services Manager (GSE) after the revocation measure becomes definitive. Starting from the…

Supreme Court Case Note Law of Obligations & Contracts
Vol. 1, Issue 1 (2026) • Art. 749 • April 29, 2026

Unjust Enrichment and Nullity of Public Contracts: Remedies Available to the Administration

Italian original: Arricchimento senza causa e nullità del contratto e azione della PA

Judgment no. 11513/2026 of the Civil United Sections of the Supreme Court of Cassation addresses a key issue regarding unjustified enrichment and the nullity of contracts involving the Public Administration due to lack of written form. Following the…

Supreme Court Case Note Law of Obligations & Contracts
Vol. 1, Issue 1 (2026) • Art. 682 • April 25, 2026

Unreviewability of Breach Materiality Under Express Contractual Termination Clauses

Italian original: L’insindacabilità della gravità nella clausola risolutiva espressa

Supreme Court order no. 31763/2025 reaffirms the principle of the unreviewability of the materiality of breach in express termination clauses. The article examines the scope of Art. 1456 of the Italian Civil Code in relation to the duty of good faith under…

Supreme Court Case Note Planning, Zoning & Construction Law
Vol. 1, Issue 1 (2026) • Art. 657 • April 25, 2026

Temporary Structures in Agricultural Zones and Ineffectiveness of Sworn Activity Notices

Italian original: I manufatti precari in zona agricola: inefficacia della CILA

This note analyzes the recent Council of State ruling no. 2176/2026 concerning the regulation of temporary structures in an agricultural zone. The research focuses on the distinction between professional and amateur use of rural land, exploring the…

Supreme Court Case Note Condominium & Real Estate Law
Vol. 1, Issue 1 (2026) • Art. 595 • April 24, 2026

Presumption of Common Property Versus Contractual Condominium Regulations

Italian original: Tra presunzione di condominialità e regolamento contrattuale

This article explores judgment no. 1830/2026 of the Rome Court of Appeal, addressing the balance between the presumption of common ownership and contractual regulations. The ruling confirms that a specific notarized title can override the presumption set by…