Statute of Scientific Autonomy, Editorial Governance & Diamond Open Access Sustainability
Foundational regulatory charter governing the institutional separation between the Publisher (Associazione Professionale Studio Legale Moscarini, Rome) and the Scientific Direction of Metodo Giuridico — Ius et Ratio (ISSN 3103-7305), safeguarding doctrinal pluralism, mandatory forensic conflict-of-interest recusal, ANVUR Area 12 evaluation standards, and permanent fee-free Diamond Open Access sustainability.
Independence of Scientific Governance from Publishing Ownership
1. Metodo Giuridico — Ius et Ratio (International Standard Serial Number ISSN 3103-7305, assigned by the Italian National ISSN Centre – CNR; telematic scholarly periodical pursuant to Art. 2 of Italian Law No. 47 of 8 February 1948, editorial seat in Rome) is an independent scientific legal journal dedicated to Italian, European, and comparative legal scholarship across all disciplines of ANVUR Area 12 (Legal Sciences).
2. The Journal does not belong to any closed academic school or professional interest group. It operates as an open, pluralistic forum accessible on equal methodological terms to university professors, tenure-track and postdoctoral researchers, doctoral candidates, magistrates, advocates, public officials, and independent legal scholars.
1. While the Journal is promoted and economically sustained by Associazione Professionale Studio Legale Moscarini (Rome) as Publisher and title proprietor, scientific governance is vested exclusively and autonomously in the Scientific Direction (Avv. Bruno Taverniti, Editor-in-Chief and Co-Scientific Director; Avv. Giovanni Ercole Moscarini, Co-Scientific Director; Avv. Federico Palumbo, Co-Scientific Director) and the Scientific Committee (Prof. Avv. Leonardo Mazza, Full Professor of Criminal Law, formerly University of Siena).
2. Neither the Publisher nor any partner, associate, or client of the promoting law firm may direct, veto, condition, or influence the evaluation, acceptance, amendment, or rejection of submitted manuscripts. Functional responsibilities are strictly partitioned as follows:
| Publisher (Ass. Prof. Studio Legale Moscarini) | Scientific Direction & Scientific Committee |
|---|---|
| Provision of server infrastructure, cybersecurity, and digital publishing platform | Exclusive definition of scholarly aims, research lines, and methodological standards |
| Administrative, fiscal, and press-law compliance (Art. 2, Law No. 47/1948; CNR ISSN) | Desk screening, assignment of double-blind external referees, and collegial evaluation |
| Endowment of Diamond Open Access costs (EUR 0 APC), DOI registration, and CERN/Zenodo preservation | Final, unappealable scholarly decisions on acceptance, revision, or rejection of manuscripts |
| Technical distribution, library cataloguing feeds (OAI-PMH, OpenAIRE, KBART, MARC 21), and outreach | Enforcement of COPE ethics, recusal rules, corrigenda/retractions, and primary-source integrity |
1. The scholarly archive of Metodo Giuridico constitutes a permanent public-interest scientific record licensed under Creative Commons CC BY-NC-ND 4.0 International, mirrored with persistent DataCite DOIs on CERN Zenodo and exposed via open harvesting protocols (OAI-PMH 2.0 / OpenAIRE v4.0).
2. Any future reorganization or change in the structure of the Publisher leaves intact the scientific autonomy of the Editorial Board, authors’ retained copyrights, and the irrevocable open-access availability of all published volumes and articles.
Safeguards Against Self-Referentiality & Professional Conflicts of Interest
1. Manuscripts are evaluated solely on deductive rigour, mastery of primary statutory and judicial sources, doctrinal depth, and original critical contribution (information gain), irrespective of the author’s academic rank or institutional affiliation.
2. Search-engine visibility and digital readership analytics serve exclusively to disseminate scholarship and identify emerging practical questions; they shall never dictate editorial selection, penalize foundational theoretical essays, or orient doctrinal conclusions.
1. Prohibition of Promotional or Litigation Use: The Journal is never used to promote the Publisher’s professional practice or to support positions in pending litigation.
2. Mandatory Recusal (Astensione Obbligatoria): Any member of the Scientific Direction, Scientific Committee, or Board of External Referees who has acted as counsel, advisor, expert witness, or arbitrator in the dispute underlying a commented decision—or who holds a direct professional or financial interest in its subject matter—is automatically recused from screening, refereeing, or deciding on the manuscript.
3. Submissions by Governance Members: Manuscripts authored or co-authored by a member of the Journal’s bodies are processed without the participation of the author concerned; Track A essays undergo independent double-blind peer review on identical terms to external submissions.
4. Author Disclosure Duty: Every author must disclose upon submission any professional representation, consultancy, or institutional role connected to the commented case so that transparent disclosure appears in the published note.
Formal Distinction of Evaluation Tracks & Annual Roll of Referees
In full alignment with Italian National Agency for the Evaluation of Universities and Research Institutes (ANVUR — Area 12, Legal Sciences) standards, every published paper, A4 monograph title page, and quarterly issue Table of Contents explicitly displays its evaluation section:
• Section I — Doctrinal Essays & Monographs (Track A — Double-Blind Peer Review): Systematic studies (minimum 12,000 characters excl. spaces) subjected to double-blind peer review by at least two independent external referees.
• Section II — Case Law & Observatory (Track B — Collegial Scientific Review & Primary-Source Audit): Critical case notes and legislative commentaries (minimum 5,000 characters excl. spaces) subjected to collegial review by the Scientific Direction paired with mandatory verification of every cited full-text judgment and statute (Zero-Second-Hand-Citations Protocol).
1. Anonymized peer-review evaluation sheets (schede di referaggio) are preserved in a confidential editorial registry for at least five years for institutional accreditation audits (ANVUR / DOAJ).
2. At the close of each annual volume—and without linking referees to individual papers so as to preserve strict double-blind anonymity—the Journal publishes on its dedicated ANVUR Sections & External Referees Hub (/en/reviewers/) the cumulative alphabetical roll of external scholars who completed peer reviews during that solar year.
Transparent Cultural Endowment & Zero-Fee Guarantee
Metodo Giuridico operates without subscription paywalls and without Article Processing Charges (EUR 0.00 submission fees; EUR 0.00 publication, typesetting, translation, and DOI fees). Operational, editorial, and digital-preservation expenses are covered entirely by a dedicated non-commercial cultural endowment provided by the Publisher.
The Journal carries no commercial advertising, sponsored articles, or paid editorial placements. Future research grants, university conventions, or institutional sponsorships may be accepted solely if publicly disclosed and strictly barred from influencing editorial governance or manuscript selection.
This Statute binds the Publisher, the Scientific Direction, the Scientific Committee, External Referees, and Contributing Authors. Adopted in Rome for Volume I (2026) and permanently published in Italian (/statuto/) and English (/en/statute/). Official enquiries: redazione@metodogiuridico.it.
