Rivista Scientifica di Diritto e Giurisprudenza
Diritto Civile • Amministrativo • Lavoro • Penale • Tributario • ISSN 3103-7305
ANVUR Area 12 Compliance • Peer Review ISSN 3103-7305 • COPE Core Practices 5-Year Audit Archive

ANVUR Evaluation Sections, Peer-Review Protocol & Annual Roll of External Referees

In compliance with Italian National Agency for the Evaluation of Universities and Research Institutes (ANVUR — Area 12, Legal Sciences) guidelines and Article 6 of our Governance Statute, Metodo Giuridico formally separates and badges its Double-Blind Peer-Reviewed Doctrinal Section (Section I) from its Source-Verified Case-Law & Observatory Section (Section II) across every HTML header, A4 PDF title page, and quarterly Table of Contents.

48 Papers
Section I • Doctrinal Essays (Double-Blind)
415 Papers
Section II • Case Law & Observatory
15–30 Days
Target Double-Blind Review Turnaround
5 Years
Confidential Referee Report Retention
ANVUR Section I • Track A

Doctrinal Essays & Monographs (Double-Blind Peer Review)

Badge on Articles & PDFs: Sec. I • Double-Blind Peer Review

Scope & Extent: Systematic doctrinal studies, dogmatic reconstructions, and comparative essays of at least 12,000 characters excluding spaces (Browse Section I Archive).

Refereeing Procedure: Following a 7-day desk check for scope and anonymization, the manuscript (stripped of all author metadata) is assigned to at least two independent external referees holding academic or judicial expertise in the relevant SSD discipline. Neither the author nor the referees know each other’s identity. In the event of conflicting reports, a third adjudicating referee is appointed.

Structured Evaluation Sheet: Assesses (1) methodological rigour; (2) completeness of primary statutory and judicial sources; (3) engagement with literature; (4) original critical thesis (information gain); (5) clarity of structure, concluding with: Accept, Revise & Resubmit, or Reject with reasoned report.

ANVUR Section II • Track B

Case Law & Observatory (Collegial Review & Source Audit)

Badge on Articles & PDFs: Sec. II • Collegial Review & Source Audit

Scope & Extent: Timely critical commentaries on landmark rulings of the Constitutional Court, Supreme Court of Cassation, Council of State, CJEU, and ECtHR of at least 5,000 characters excluding spaces (Browse Section II Archive).

Evaluation & Source Protocol: Evaluated collegially by the Scientific Direction (with mandatory recusal of any co-author or interested practitioner) paired with our deterministic Zero-Second-Hand-Citations Audit: every cited judgment and statutory clause must be materialized in full official text and verified across court, jurisdictional branch, decision number, and literal statutory wording.

ANVUR Separation Guarantee: Express visual badging ensures evaluators and readers immediately distinguish rapid-turnaround Section II commentaries from double-blind peer-reviewed Section I essays.

Public Referee Accountability • Art. 7 Governance Statute

Annual Alphabetical Roll of External Referees (Albo Annuale dei Revisori)

In accordance with ANVUR Area 12 best practices and COPE Ethical Guidelines for Peer Reviewers, Metodo Giuridico protects the strict anonymity of individual referee assignments while ensuring full institutional transparency: external referees are never associated with specific published articles, and their cumulative alphabetical list (full name, academic rank or judicial/Bar qualification, and institutional affiliation) is published annually upon closure of each solar volume.

Official Status — Volume I (Solar Year 2026)

Volume 1 (2026) — Open Inaugural Annual Volume: Pursuant to Article 7 of the Governance Statute and to safeguard the confidentiality of double-blind evaluations currently in progress during the inaugural year, the consolidated alphabetical roll of External Referees for Volume 1 (2026) will be published on this page upon closure of the 2026 annual volume (after 31 December 2026). Individual evaluation sheets are archived in the Editorial Direction’s five-year confidential registry.

Academic Community • Call for External Referees

Accreditation to the Board of External Referees (Area 12 & Comparative Law)

The Scientific Direction and Scientific Committee welcome expressions of availability to serve as independent double-blind peer reviewers from Full and Associate Professors, Tenure-Track and Postdoctoral Researchers, Research Doctors (PhDs), Magistrates, and Specialist Advocates across Italian, European Union, and comparative legal disciplines (Italian ministerial sectors GIUR-01/A–GIUR-17/A, formerly IUS/01–IUS/21).

Prospective referees may transmit a brief academic curriculum vitae, primary disciplinary sectors, languages of review (Italian and/or English), and ORCID iD to redazione@metodogiuridico.it.

Submit External Referee Accreditation →