Rivista Scientifica di Diritto e Giurisprudenza
Diritto Civile • Amministrativo • Lavoro • Penale • Tributario • ISSN 3103-7305
ISSN 3103-7305 • Case-Law Conflict Tracker Per-Question RSS Alerts

Controversial Judicial Questions & Doctrinal Splits

Synoptic dossiers curated by Metodo Giuridico on high-litigation fractures across Italian Civil, Administrative, Labour, Criminal, and Tax law. Every dossier maps the practical legal question, contrasts Thesis A and Thesis B, documents Supreme/Constitutional Court guidance, and links dynamically to verified Citator rulings and full-text journal papers.

Administrative Law & Procurement Active Case-by-Case Balancing (Equal Treatment vs. Result Principle)

Scope of Mandatory Bid-Cure (Soccorso Istruttorio) vs. Non-Curable Technical and Financial Bid Omissions

Art. 101 Legislative Decree no. 36/2023 (Public Contracts Code); Arts. 1–3 D.Lgs. 36/2023; Art. 56(3) Dir. 2014/24/EU

Where does the boundary lie between mandatory procedural cure under Art. 101 of the 2023 Public Contracts Code and prohibited post-deadline modification of technical or economic tenders when a bidder omits…

0 cases · 53 papers Open Dossier →
Tax Law & Tax Litigation Enacted Statutory Reform — Litigation on Carve-Outs & Pre-Reform Assessments

Generalized Pre-Assessment Tax Hearing (Art. 6-bis Law 212/2000), Ministerial Carve-Outs & Outcome-Resistance Test

Art. 6-bis Law no. 212/2000 (Taxpayer’s Bill of Rights); Art. 7-bis Law Decree no. 39/2024; Ministerial Decree 24 April 2024

How strictly must Tax Courts construe statutory carve-outs from the mandatory 60-day pre-assessment hearing under Art. 6-bis Law 212/2000 ("substantially automated acts", "collection jeopardy"), and what t…

0 cases · 24 papers Open Dossier →
Civil Law & Civil Procedure Joint Divisions Framework Settled — Fact-Intensive Application on Hazard Visibility

Strict Custodial Liability (Art. 2051 c.c.) and Victim Negligence as Autonomous Caso Fortuito

Art. 2051 Civil Code; Art. 1227(1) Civil Code; Art. 2 Italian Constitution

Given the purely objective nature of custodial liability under Art. 2051 c.c., when does a claimant’s own inattention toward a visible defect (such as a road pothole or wet floor) rise to an autonomous for…

0 cases · 16 papers Open Dossier →
Civil Law & Civil Procedure Partial Nullity Settled by Joint Divisions — Active Disputes on Specific Guarantees & Art. 1957 c.c.

Bank Guarantees Reproducing the Anticompetitive ABI Model: Specific Guarantees, Proof of Cartel & Art. 1957 c.c. Bar

Arts. 1419, 1936 and 1957 Civil Code; Art. 2 Law no. 287/1990 (Competition Act); Bank of Italy Order no. 55/2005

Following Joint Divisions precedent establishing partial nullity of survival, revival, and Art. 1957 c.c. waiver clauses in omnibus bank guarantees tracking the 2003 ABI cartel template, does privileged ev…

0 cases · 23 papers Open Dossier →
Administrative Law & Procurement Interpretive Tension on Art. 21-nonies(2-bis) & Constructive Building Permits

Ex Officio Administrative Annulment Beyond the 12-Month Cap, Misrepresentation & Legitimate Expectations

Art. 21-nonies(1) and (2-bis) Law no. 241/1990; Art. 2(8-bis) Law no. 241/1990

Does overriding the strict 12-month time bar on retroactive administrative self-annulment under Art. 21-nonies(2-bis) Law 241/1990 strictly require a final criminal conviction for forgery/perjury, or can a…

0 cases · 57 papers Open Dossier →
Labour & Social Security Law Reshaped by Constitutional Court — Split Between Restructuring Fact & Repêchage

Economic Dismissal (Giustificato Motivo Oggettivo): Scope of Repêchage & Reinstatement vs. Indemnity Remedies

Art. 3 Law no. 604/1966; Art. 18(7) Law no. 300/1970; Art. 3(1)–(2) Legislative Decree no. 23/2015

Following Constitutional Court interventions reshaping Art. 18 of the Workers’ Statute and Legislative Decree no. 23/2015 (Jobs Act), does an employer’s breach of the redeployment duty (repêchage)—where th…

0 cases · 18 papers Open Dossier →
Tax Law & Tax Litigation Evidentiary Tension Between Audit Presumptions & EU VAT Neutrality

Subjectively Non-Existent VAT Transactions: Burden of Proving Buyer Knowledge/Diligence Under Reformed Art. 7(5-bis)

Art. 19 Presidential Decree no. 633/1972 (VAT Decree); Art. 7(5-bis) D.Lgs. 546/1992; Art. 168 Directive 2006/112/EC

To deny input VAT deduction where goods were genuinely delivered by a supplier later Exposed as a "missing trader" (shell company), what concrete objective indicators must the Tax Administration prove unde…

0 cases · 22 papers Open Dossier →
Criminal Law & Procedure Recent Cautionary Reform — Supreme Court Consolidation Underway

Pre-Cautionary Judicial Interrogation (Art. 291(1-quater) c.p.p.): Carve-Outs, Discovery Scope & Nullity Regime

Art. 291(1-quater)–(1-novies) Code of Criminal Procedure; Art. 292(2-ter) and (3-bis) c.p.p. (Law no. 114/2024)

When a Judge for Preliminary Investigations (GIP) bypasses pre-cautionary interrogation by invoking risk of flight or evidence tampering, and the Review Court (Tribunale del riesame) subsequently strikes d…

0 cases · 30 papers Open Dossier →
Criminal Law & Procedure Active Doctrinal Line-Drawing (Crypto-Assets, Gambling & Financial Investments)

Boundary Between Punishable Self-Laundering (Art. 648-ter.1 c.p.) and the Personal-Enjoyment Safe Harbour

Art. 648-ter.1(1) and (4) Criminal Code; Art. 648-bis c.p.; Art. 25-octies Legislative Decree no. 231/2001

When does channelling proceeds of a predicate crime (tax fraud, embezzlement, cyber-fraud) into financial instruments, gambling, real estate, or crypto-asset wallets constitute punishable "speculative acti…

0 cases · 12 papers Open Dossier →
Civil Law & Civil Procedure Cassation Framework Consolidated — Strict Pleading & Appreciability Requirements

Compensability of Patrimonial and Medical Loss of Chance: Seriousness Threshold, Event Uncertainty & Equitable Quantification

Arts. 1223, 1226, 2043, 2056 and 2059 Civil Code

How do Italian courts separate full causal recovery for the final adverse outcome ("more probable than not") from proportional damages for "loss of chance" (especially in delayed cancer diagnosis and publi…

0 cases · 17 papers Open Dossier →
Civil Law & Civil Procedure Joint Divisions Principles Established — Evidentiary Scrutiny of Shared Sacrifices

Post-Divorce Maintenance: Counting Pre-Marital Cohabitation & Survival of Compensatory Alimony Upon New Cohabitation

Art. 5(6) and (10) Law no. 898/1970 (Divorce Act); Arts. 2 and 29 Italian Constitution

When determining composite post-divorce maintenance (assistential and compensatory-equalizing), must courts count years of stable pre-marital cohabitation, and does the recipient’s entry into a new stable…

0 cases · 6 papers Open Dossier →
Administrative Law & Procurement Plenary Assembly Standards Set — Fast-Track Tender Redaction Litigation (Art. 36 D.Lgs. 36/2023)

Defensive Documentary Access (Art. 24(7) Law 241/1990): Strict Necessity Nexus vs. Privacy & Trade Secrets

Arts. 22 and 24(7) Law no. 241/1990; Arts. 35–36 Legislative Decree no. 36/2023; Art. 9 GDPR

How specifically must an applicant demonstrate a "strict necessity link" under Art. 24(7) Law 241/1990 to compel disclosure of administrative records containing third-party personal data, sensitive health/…

0 cases · 38 papers Open Dossier →
Labour & Social Security Law Strong Anti-Discrimination Precedent — Litigation on Employer Knowledge & Union Clauses

Sick-Leave Cap (Comporto) Exceeded by Workers with Disabilities: Indirect Discrimination & Reasonable Accommodation

Art. 2110(2) Civil Code; Arts. 2 and 3(3-bis) Legislative Decree no. 216/2003; Art. 5 Directive 2000/78/EC

Does applying a collective agreement’s uniform maximum sick-leave cap (periodo di comporto) to a worker with a disability (under the autonomous EU bio-psychosocial definition) constitute unlawful indirect…

0 cases · 12 papers Open Dossier →
Criminal Law & Procedure Criminal Joint Divisions Landmark Turn — Ongoing Precautionary & Trial Implementation

Value-Based Confiscation Among Co-Offenders: Rejection of Joint Solidarity in Favour of Individual Share Apportionment

Arts. 240 and 322-ter Criminal Code; Art. 12-bis Legislative Decree no. 74/2000; Art. 27 Const.; Art. 49(3) CFREU

Where multiple co-defendants jointly commit an offence and direct proceeds cannot be traced, may criminal courts impose punitive value-based confiscation (confisca per equivalente)—or pre-trial freezing or…

0 cases · 49 papers Open Dossier →
Civil Law & Civil Procedure Rapidly Evolving Specialized Business Court Jurisprudence

Adequate Corporate Governance Structures (Art. 2086(2) c.c.) & Limits of the Business Judgment Rule

Art. 2086(2) Civil Code; Arts. 2381, 2392, 2409 and 2476 Civil Code; Art. 3 Legislative Decree no. 14/2019 (CCII)

How deeply may Specialized Business Courts scrutinize the adequacy of internal governance, accounting, and early-warning structures under Art. 2086(2) c.c.—even in solvent companies via Art. 2409 c.c. judi…

0 cases · 9 papers Open Dossier →
Labour & Social Security Law Strict Proportionality Balancing Under Cassation & ECtHR Jurisprudence

Employer Technological "Defensive Checks" (Art. 4 Workers’ Statute): Prior Reasonable Suspicion, GDPR Proportionality & Admissibility

Art. 4 Law no. 300/1970 (Workers’ Statute); Arts. 5, 6 and 88 Regulation (EU) 2016/679 (GDPR); Art. 8 ECHR

Under what conditions may an employer rely in dismissal proceedings on evidence extracted from corporate email accounts, IT logs, or GPS/video devices without a prior union agreement under Art. 4(1) Worker…

0 cases · 72 papers Open Dossier →
Tax Law & Tax Litigation Settled by Constitutional Court & CJEU — Ongoing Disputes on Intra-Textual Clauses

Corporate M&A Recharacterization in Registration Tax: Strict Single-Deed Rule (Art. 20 TUR) vs. Anti-Abuse (Art. 10-bis)

Art. 20 Presidential Decree no. 131/1986 (TUR); Art. 10-bis Law no. 212/2000; Art. 53 Italian Constitution

Under reformed Art. 20 of the Registration Tax Act (upheld by both the Constitutional Court and CJEU), may the Revenue Agency recharacterize multi-step M&A transactions (such as a business contribution fol…

0 cases · 69 papers Open Dossier →