Rivista Scientifica di Diritto e Giurisprudenza
Diritto Civile • Amministrativo • Lavoro • Penale • Tributario • ISSN 3103-7305
ISSN 3103-7305 • Metodo Giuridico Diamond Open Access • EUR 0 APCs Aligned with COPE Practices & DOAJ Criteria Versione Italiana (IT) →

Publication Ethics, Peer Review, Open Access & Digital Preservation Policies

Official Governance & Transparency Charter of Metodo Giuridico — Ius et Ratio (ISSN 3103-7305, Rome, Italy), drafted in full compliance with the Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing (COPE / DOAJ / OASPA / WAME, 4th ed.), the Budapest Open Access Initiative (BOAI), and the technical standards of the DOAJ Seal.

Section 1 • Editorial Evaluation & Refereeing

1. Editorial Process & Double-Blind Peer Review Policy

Every manuscript submitted to Metodo Giuridico undergoes an initial desk assessment for scholarly scope, originality, and documentary completeness by the Editorial Board (Direzione Scientifica: Avv. Bruno Taverniti, Editor-in-Chief; Avv. Giovanni Ercole Moscarini; Avv. Federico Palumbo), followed by a transparent genre-specific evaluation procedure:

  • Doctrinal Essays & Monographs (Approfondimenti): subject to mandatory double-blind peer review by at least two independent specialists in the relevant legal field (university professors, magistrates, or senior legal scholars coordinated with the Scientific Committee), preserving strict mutual anonymity between authors and referees. Reviewers evaluate doctrinal rigour, command of statutory and judicial sources, analytical originality, and clarity, recommending: (a) unconditional acceptance; (b) acceptance subject to revisions; or (c) reasoned rejection.
  • Supreme Court Case Notes & Legislative Commentaries (Note a Sentenza): subject to rigorous editorial peer review by the Editorial Board combined with a mandatory full-text primary-source audit of every judicial decision and legislative act discussed.
  • Submissions by Editorial Board or Scientific Committee Members: whenever a manuscript is authored or co-authored by a member of the Editorial Board or Scientific Committee, that member is recused from all editorial handling, reviewer selection, and publication decisions, which are conducted independently by non-conflicted editors and external referees.

Average desk-screening turnaround: 7 working days; full peer-review cycle: 15–30 days. Anonymised referee reports are archived confidentially by the Editorial Office for a minimum of five years.

Section 2 • Zero-Second-Hand-Citations Engineering Standard

2. Primary-Source Verification Protocol & Policy on Computational / AI Tools

A defining hallmark of Metodo Giuridico is its strict Zero-Second-Hand-Citations Verification Protocol, engineered to prevent indirect headnote reliance, unverifiable references, or citation inaccuracies:

  • Mandatory Full-Text Primary Judicial Sources: no judicial ruling (Constitutional Court, Supreme Court of Cassation, Council of State, CJEU, ECtHR, trial/appellate courts, or independent authorities) may be cited in the text or footnotes unless its complete official text has been retrieved from authoritative institutional repositories and verified across its identifying coordinates (court, jurisdictional division/Joint Divisions, form of decision, number, and year).
  • Deterministic Statutory Quote Verification: verbatim quotation marks (« ») are reserved exclusively for official legislative texts in force, verified word-for-word against official gazettes (Normattiva / EUR-Lex), whereas case law is analysed through attributed technical paraphrase.
  • 1:1 Synchronized Bilingual Paragraph Numbering (§): papers published with an International English Edition preserve strict 1:1 paragraph parity (§ 1, § 2, …, § N) between the Italian original and the unabridged English translation, enabling exact cross-lingual pinpoint citations in OSCOLA, Bluebook, APA, and Italian legal styles.
  • Responsible Use of Computational & AI Tools (COPE Policy): any computational, editorial, or AI-assisted workflows employed for translation, formatting, or deterministic source-checking never substitute human authorship, legal reasoning, or editorial accountability, and are strictly barred from introducing any unverified source.
Section 3 • Research Integrity & Malpractice Statement

3. Publication Ethics & Research Integrity Statement (COPE Core Practices)

The Journal adheres to the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) Core Practices across all stages of publication:

  • Duties of Editors & Reviewers: manuscripts are evaluated solely on intellectual and legal merit without regard to race, gender, institutional affiliation, nationality, or political philosophy. Referees treat manuscripts as confidential documents and recuse themselves in the event of any professional, collaborative, or financial conflict of interest.
  • Originality, Plagiarism Screening & Authorship: authors warrant that submissions are entirely original, free from plagiarism, redundant publication, or documentary fabrication, and credit only individuals who made a substantial intellectual contribution. All submissions are screened for originality prior to publication.
  • Conflicts of Interest Disclosure: authors must disclose any litigation representation, consultancy, or financial relationship directly connected to a commented case or legislative measure; disclosures are published transparently in a footnote.
  • Data Protection & Case-Law Anonymisation: in compliance with Article 52 of Italian Legislative Decree No. 196/2003 and Regulation (EU) 2016/679 (GDPR), personal identifiers of private litigants, minors, and vulnerable persons are systematically anonymised.
Section 4 • Integrity of the Permanent Scholarly Record

4. Policy on Corrections, Retractions & Expressions of Concern

In accordance with the COPE Retraction Guidelines, published articles form part of the permanent scholarly record (ISSN 3103-7305 & DataCite DOI) and are never silently altered or deleted:

  • Erratum / Corrigendum: material or typographical errors that do not compromise the validity of the legal analysis are corrected via a dated notice appended transparently to the article.
  • Retractions & Expressions of Concern: if substantiated evidence of severe source inaccuracy, plagiarism, or ethical breach emerges post-publication, the Editorial Board — after offering the author an opportunity to respond — issues a formal, reasoned Retraction Notice (or interim Expression of Concern) permanently linked to the original URL and DataCite DOI record.
Section 5 • Barrier-Free Legal Scholarship

5. Diamond Open Access Policy & Zero-Fee Guarantee (EUR 0 APCs)

Metodo Giuridico is a native Diamond Open Access law review compliant with the Budapest Open Access Initiative (BOAI) and DOAJ criteria:

Reader Access100% immediate and free access to full-text HTML articles and A4 PDF monographs (Italian & English editions), with zero embargo and no registration requirement.
Submission FeesEUR 0.00 (None) — manuscript submission, desk review, and peer review are completely free of charge.
Article Processing Charges (APCs)EUR 0.00 (Zero APCs / Zero Page Charges) — neither authors nor their institutions are ever charged fees for publication, typesetting, English edition production, or DOI registration.
User Rights (BOAI)Readers may freely read, download, copy, distribute, print, search, cite, or link to the full texts of all articles for any lawful non-commercial purpose without prior permission from the Publisher or the Author, subject to the terms of the CC BY-NC-ND 4.0 license.
Section 7 • Repository Deposit Policy (Jisc Open Policy Finder / Sherpa-Romeo)

7. Immediate Zero-Embargo Self-Archiving Policy

Authors are permitted and encouraged to deposit immediately upon publication, with zero embargo (0 months):

  • the Submitted Version (Preprint);
  • the Author Accepted Manuscript (AAM); and
  • the published Version of Record (VoR — Publisher’s official A4 PDF, both Italian and English editions);

in any institutional university repository (including IRIS / CINECA, OpenAIRE), personal academic webpage, or disciplinary open archive (SSRN, Zenodo), accompanied by bibliographic attribution to Metodo Giuridico (ISSN 3103-7305) and a link to the canonical URL or DOI.

Section 8 • Long-Term Archiving & Library Interoperability (DOAJ Seal Criteria)

8. Digital Preservation, Persistent DOIs & OAI-PMH 2.0 Harvesting

Long-Term Digital Preservation & DOIsFull-text A4 PDFs (English and Italian editions) are deposited for permanent bit-level preservation at Zenodo (operated by CERN in Geneva within the European Commission’s OpenAIRE infrastructure), with persistent DataCite DOIs (10.5281/zenodo.*) and multi-replica archival storage in the CERN Data Centre, supplemented by Internet Archive crawls.
OAI-PMH 2.0 Repository EndpointLive harvesting endpoint for DOAJ, OpenAIRE, BASE, and university library catalogues: https://www.metodogiuridico.it/oai (oai_dc + OpenAIRE v4 info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccess).
Article-Level Metadata StandardsEvery article exposes Highwire Press (citation_*) for Google Scholar, Dublin Core (DC.*), PRISM, Schema.org ScholarlyArticle JSON-LD, direct .RIS (Zotero/Mendeley/EndNote) & .BIB (BibTeX) endpoints, and an English Scholarly XML Sitemap.
Section 9 • Ownership, Revenue Sources & Editorial Independence

9. Ownership, Non-Commercial Funding & Advertising Policy

  • Publisher & Funding Model: Metodo Giuridico (ISSN 3103-7305; Editorial Office: Rome, Italy; Contact: redazione@metodogiuridico.it) is published and funded entirely through internal non-commercial patronage by Associazione Professionale Studio Legale Moscarini (Rome, Italy).
  • Editorial Independence & Direct Marketing: editorial decisions are governed strictly by scholarly merit and independent of any commercial or financial consideration. No commercial advertising influences editorial content, and any academic announcements or calls for papers are conducted truthfully, unobtrusively, and in strict compliance with COPE direct-marketing standards.
International Cataloguing & Editorial Enquiries • ISSN 3103-7305
Explore our full-text English papers, Editorial Board directory, or OAI-PMH 2.0 metadata repository.